Discussion on Accounting Treatment of Promotional Credits for Car-Sharing Companies
An employee of a car-sharing company asks whether free ride credits (not redeemable for cash) issued to new customer accounts to promote new business need to be accounted for in the balance sheet. The article analyzes the nature of these credits and points out that they may constitute deferred revenue or contract liabilities, suggesting reference to relevant accounting standards.
I currently work at a car-sharing company. To promote our new business, we issue credits to new customer accounts for free rides. My question is simple: Do I need to do anything regarding these outstanding credits on the balance sheet? My initial reaction is no, because they cannot be redeemed for cash, but I am not entirely sure.
Regarding this question, the nature of these promotional credits needs to be examined from an accounting perspective. Under current revenue recognition standards (such as IFRS 15 or ASC 606), reward credits provided to customers generally constitute a 'material right,' meaning the customer is entitled to obtain goods or services at a discount or for free in the future. Therefore, the entity should allocate the transaction price to the reward credits and recognize revenue when the customer exercises the right or when the credits expire.
Specifically in the car-sharing scenario, although free ride credits are not redeemable for cash, customers can use them to enjoy free services, which essentially represents additional consideration for services provided by the entity to the customer. Therefore, when issuing the credits, the entity should recognize a contract liability (or deferred revenue) for the estimated standalone selling price of the credits. When customers use the credits for rides, the corresponding liability should be transferred to main business revenue.
If the credits have no expiration date and there is no historical data on expiration, the liability will remain on the books until customers use them or until the entity assesses the likelihood of exercise and writes them off. If the credits have a clear expiration date, the unexercised portion should be reversed to revenue (or offset against promotional expenses, depending on policy) at the expiration date.
Additionally, it is necessary to consider whether the credits constitute 'consideration payable to a customer.' If the credits are essentially cash equivalents paid to customers, they may need to be treated as a reduction of revenue. However, given that the credits are not redeemable for cash and are only used to exchange for the entity's own services, they are generally not considered consideration payable to a customer, but rather fall under the scope of contract liabilities.
Therefore, it is recommended that you consult the applicable accounting standards (such as Chinese Accounting Standard No. 14 - Revenue) and evaluate the fair value and expected exercise rate of the credits. If the amount is material, the relevant accounting policies and changes in balances should be disclosed in the notes to the financial statements. If the amount is immaterial, simplified treatment may be acceptable, but consistency should still be maintained.
In summary, your initial reaction that 'no treatment is needed' may not be accurate. It is advisable to communicate with the finance team or external auditors to ensure compliance. If the credits are only a one-time promotion and the amount is insignificant, in practice they may be expensed directly, but this should be determined based on the principle of materiality.